Monday, July 23, 2012

Lazy Fingers ?


I'm going to talk a bit about using the fingers of the left hand for fretting. Not every traditional player uses a noter- some traditional drone style players use their fingers or 'fingerdance' while playing. Others play in both traditional and modern styles. I'd like to discuss a very common problem I see when fretting with the fingers, in hopes that it will help some readers here, both fingerdance and chord style players.

Many beginner mountain dulcimer players, especially those with no prior stringed instrument experience, play with their fretting hand held low and flat with the fingertips lying down on the strings while playing, pressing the notes with the fatty pads of their fingers. It looks like they are pressing the edge of a pie crust together, or typing on a keyboard. Almost every beginner banjo student I've ever had has done this as well. This way of fretting compensates for lack of hand and finger muscle strength and a lack of fingertip calluses. It helps prevent typical beginner fretting soreness and feels like a natural extension of our comfortable and familiar computer fingerboard typing position. But there is a big downside...

While understandably favored by beginners, this 'lazy fingers' fretting position can easily become a habit that produces unclear or muffled musical tones, and severely restricts your playing dexterity later on. The fleshy pad of the finger is wide and tends to accidentally mute or buzz adjacent strings. It also causes the double melody strings to separate, because you wind up sort of pushing the strings as you press down. Remember, you only need enough pressure to depress the strings down to the fret, not necessarily down to the wooden fretboard surface. The harder you press, the more you push and bend the string and distort the sound, leading to buzzes and poor intonation.
Using an adjacent finger as a strengthening 'crutch' by pressing it together with the fretting finger (another common beginner habit) further prevents the player from stretching the hand, building finger muscle strength, and moving the fingers freely from note to note.
Sliding is difficult on the fleshy finger pads, whereas hard callused fingertips slide beautifully. Imagine trying to run while you are lying down!  Playing calluses will not build up on the fatty pads like they would on the very end of the fingertip bone, and it's those hard calluses and strong finger muscles that help stringed musicians produce their nice clear notes and slide about quickly from note to note. Every time you feel some soreness from playing on the tips of your fingers, know that your wonderful hard musician calluses are beginning to form! The more you play, the less sore and less difficult it will feel.

Raise your left hand UP and arched directly over the strings, as though it is an umbrella protecting the strings from the rain. Lower your fingers vertically straight down when fretting. On all fingers except the thumb, fret with the very tip of the finger, the end of the finger bone. This is where you will build your callouses. The thumb should fret on its edge, again near the tip of the thumb. You will develop a very hard callous there too, on the skin to the right side of your thumbnail bed. Fretting with these hard callused bone tips instead your soft fatty pads will produce clear tones and notes, and your freely mobile arched hand will allow for quick movement between positions on your fretboard. This will enable longer stretches in making chords!  As you play this way more and more, you will find that your fingers can actually make longer stretches when making chords- stretches that were physically impossible or uncomfortable at first. I learned this for myself, and was amazed.

So get your hand arched UP and play on the very tips of your fingers.  Think of your fingers as ballerina feet 'on point'.  You are not typing, kneading dough, or pinching pie crusts.  Play proudly and assertively, no matter how brand new you are to playing your dulcimer!
                             
________________________________________________

This is a big issue for beginners, who often suffer from sore fingers, don't have strong hands, and have a hard time getting a clear sound.But it's not so difficult to improve your tone by changing your hand positions slightly. The first step is in recognizing a problem. 

Do you recognize yourself in any of the following pictures?...

In DAd tuning, here is the 'lazy' 1-0-1 "A" chord fretting position. Fingers are lying flat, fretting with the fleshy pads and having to push down too hard to get a good note.


Here is it shown again using different fingers- notice the index finger being used as a 'crutch' to strengthen the fretting finger.  Not good!
This is a better way to get good tone while fretting on the bony tips of your fingers.

Here again, the 'lazy fingers' position for fretting a 3-1-0 "G" chord in DAd tuning.

Here is the same 3-1-0 chord, cleanly fretted with an arched and relaxed hand.

Here is the 'Lazy Fingers' way of fretting a 5-3-3 "G" chord in DAd tuning. Notice how the middle string can get pushed to one side, creating poor intonation.

Arching up to the tips of the fingers when fretting the 5-3-3 chord results in strong hand muscles, clear tone, good intonation,, helpful string musician calluses, and nimbleness of movement when playing.

18 comments:

  1. Thank you! I was exactly at the "bad" point and will now do it properly!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, very informatitve! My parents own a dulcimer shop and I did not even know that. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Just got my mountain dulcimer yesterday. I'm clueless when it comes to music. So this website is going to be my teacher.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for the finger bone lesson. I will try a simple song to hear the difference. Special thanks for using the "Beginner" tag. With so much information, I totally depend on those tags.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very interesting and insightful. I notice that I use bad form when my nails start growing out too, so I have to remember to trim those nails so they don't get in the way of good sound and am able to use the tips of the fingers.

    ReplyDelete
  6. for a older person to try an learn cords is a little bit harder to learn is repetition the best way?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Guilty! I've been trying to break this bad habit I've picked up. Thanks for the pics of the right way to do it!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks. I am quite guilty of this. Ill try to be more mindful of it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This is great information. I'm just starting out and hopefully will avoid one bad habit.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks for this information. I'm a beginner, who was using the "lazy" chording method. Compared your way and mine. What a difference. Thanks! Thinking of my fingers being "en pointe," like ballet dancers, really helps.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thanks. I just started playing a few weeks ago and I'm still trying out the best positions/way to do chords. The first week I was holding my hand in a very twisted position for certain chords and started getting elbow pain. The photographs are extremely helpful. I'm going to cut my nails (again) and try playing this way.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thank you. This explains a lot! Could never figure out how I was going to get fast enough and not bump into all the strings.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thank You. I felt something was wrong. This has helped a lot. I look forward to your next posting.

    ReplyDelete
  14. wonderful advice, I am a beginner and find myself lazing off too, I will watch for that now, thank you so much

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thanks-I really needed to know that - I see the big difference. I've been just plunking for a while since my neighbor gave me a dulcimer. Then a day or so ago I found this Group online and your link- just what I was looking for!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Any suggestions on how to maintain the calluses? mine always peel off after they get thick

    ReplyDelete
  17. Great,I have been fretting wrong,pressing too hard,I have been playing one year and a half, thanks for your help !!!

    ReplyDelete
  18. This is my first reading of the blog. I am a true beginner. Just bought a dulcimer 2 weeks ago. I play classical guitar, so I do have calluses. Yeah!

    ReplyDelete